Judgment Schema

Before AI acts, it must know whether its judgment is legitimate.

FineSchema represents judgment as a structured schema. Every decision is decomposed into object, evidence, causality, category, modality, uncertainty, and consequence.

Components of a judgment

Six questions every decision must answer.

Object

What is being judged?

무엇에 대한 판단인가?

Evidence

What evidence supports the judgment?

어떤 근거가 있는가?

Causality

Is the cause actually connected to the effect?

원인과 결과가 실제로 연결되는가?

Modality

Is it certain, likely, possible, or unknown?

확실한가, 가능한가, 추정인가?

Consequence

What happens if this judgment becomes action?

이 판단이 행동으로 이어질 때 어떤 위험이 있는가?

Error detection

The defects FineSchema looks for.

Overgeneralization

Evidence Gap

Causal Fallacy

Category Error

Contradiction

Protected-Class Proxy

Temporal Impossibility

Unjustified Certainty

Bad judgment

“All customers with chargebacks are fraudsters.”

BlockedOvergeneralization. A chargeback is a risk signal, not sufficient evidence of fraud.